Air braked wagon development
Please note the air braked era is not an area of particular interest
to me. I have made notes in case I started to model this period but there may
well be errors in the text and or the illustrations that follow.
On
what is primarily seen as a passenger railway system the demand for ever higher
speeds and development of improved suspension and braking systems has
continued. Whereas the pre-war goods trains had typical speeds for unfitted
stock of only 25 miles per hour, current practice calls for air-braked stock
operating at speeds of 60 mph or more when fully laden. These higher speeds do
not confer any real commercial advantage, it is generally agreed that railway
freight moved at speeds of 40-50 mph is probably the best compromise between
efficiency and economy. The additional cost of building the high speed rolling
stock has probably cost the railways some business, they do however make life
much easier for the people routing trains. In the USA, where the economics of
the late 20th century have just about killed all but commuter passenger
traffic, most lines are basically freight only. Average speeds of 30 mph or
less are not uncommon, with many lines restricted to a maximum of 50 mph even
for passenger stock.
Vehicles fitted with both air and vacuum brakes
were built for ferry traffic in the pre-war era and more were built by BR. In
the 1960's BR conducted a series of experiments compare air and vacuum brake
systems, making much use of the ferry stock to do this.
As well as the
ferry vehicles they built a series of prototype wagons, starting in about 1962
with a small number of 'tube' wagons. I believe these were essentially the same
as the later OAA (as available from Grafar) but I have not found any
photographs to confirm what they looked like.
Several experimental open
wagon and van designs were then built using a common air-braked chassis (one of
the curtain sided experimental vans from a batch built in 1966 is included in
the sketch below). These were judged a success and British Railways set about
building a fleet of open and closed vehicles on this standard chassis . This
was before TOPS and the new vans and open wagons were coded COV-AB and
OPEN-AB.
The initial British Railways standard four wheel air-braked
wagon chassis appeared in 1969 and was 33 ft. 6 ins (10211 mm) over all length
with a wheel base of 24 ft. 9 ins (6324 mm). This chassis was developed from a
small number of prototypes. The 'standard' was somewhat flexible however and
there were variations in the suspension and the positioning of the brake
handles. One point to note is that the brake gear under the wagon was offset to
one end, so the brake handles were different on each side of the
chassis.
Fig___ BR standard AB chassis
The early form
of air braked chassis is used by Graham Farish and Taylor Plastic Models for
their modern image models and the latter firm also offer the basic chassis as a
separate item.
It was decided that the air brakes, which require less
bulky equipment on the wagon, were preferable for modern stock. Series
production of air braked vehicles for purely British use began in 1964. First
to appear was the HOP 32 AB merry go round hopper wagon (now coded HAA)
followed by the small-wheeled bogie Freightliner flat wagons (now coded FFA and
FGA) and the Cartic Four car carriers (TOPS coded PQA for PO types, FQA for
British Rail owned stock). The Cartics and other similar vehicles are discussed
later in this section.
The HOP 32 AB mineral hoppers (TOPS coded
HAA/HDA/HFA) used for supplying power stations with coal became the most common
single type of wagon in the modern fleet. They have a chassis which is 27 foot
2½ ins (8001mm) over the headstocks with a wheel base of 18 foot 11 ins
(5561mm). A model of this vehicle was available from Minitrix.
Quite
early on, before TOPS was introduced, fifty seven of the HAA hoppers were
fitted with a solid roof equipped with what appears to be a single hatch
running the length of the top (I have yet to find a photograph showing the tops
of these wagons). Originally coded COVHOP 32 AB, changing to CBA under TOPS,
they have been used for lime traffic as recently as 1995. I had thought from
photographs that they were painted 'freight brown' rather than the plain metal
of the standard HAAs but I understand that they were in fact just very dirty.
There was presumably a CAA covered hopper but to date I have traced no
information on these and they may not actually have been built. The last major
order for wagons by BR before privatisation was for a conversion to more of the
HAA hoppers for china clay traffic. Built in 1988 and TOPS coded CDA these have
a power operated canvass roof, rising to a central longitudinal roller device.
I believe the body of the wagon is painted white but I am not sure about that.
(There is a conversion kit available for the Minitrix HAA to convert it into a
CDA)
Following the prototypes of 1966 the first open wagons for the new fleet were the 31 ton payload/45
ton GLW OPEN-AB (TOPS coded OAA) open wagons. These were introduced in 1971 and
a model is available from Graham Farish. Wooden bodied the sides were made up
of three drop down doors with removable stanchions so the whole side could be
opened for loading. These wagons were supplied with their own green tarpaulins,
marked 'TO BE RETAINED WITH AB WAGONS ONLY'. Cargo for these wagons has
included various palletised loads such as bricks and roof tiles, large crates,
steel bars and (with a tarpaulin added) bags of grain and rolls of newsprint.
Several of these wagons were transferred to departmental use and were re-coded
ZDA 'Squid'.
An alternative wooden bodied open design was the OBA
(available as an etched kit in the John Grey range). The prototype was built in
1974 on a redundant steel carrying SCA chassis (which had itself been converted
from an OAA). Series production of the type began in 1977 an this proved to be
a successful design. The OBA has sides made up of four drop doors, again with
removable stanchions to allow the whole side to be opened for loading. The
floor has bolsters which can be folded down out of the way when not required,
allowing loads of steel to be carried. The ends are two planks higher than the
sides to support a tarpaulin and loads would be as for the OAA above. By the
mid 1990's most OBA's had transferred to the departmental fleet, re-coded ZDA
'Bass' but quite a few were sold and formed the basis of a number of Private
Owner vehicles.
The OCA, introduced in 1981 is a steel bodied open
wagon, still with drop down sides in three sections and with removable
stanchions. The floor is fitted with a series of bolsters which are not
removable, these were added to allow the wagon to be loaded with hot steel
sections. The OCA wagons were originally built on redundant steel wagon chassis
and loads would again be as for the OAA but they were built for carrying steel
and were often used for coils of steel wire.
Air braked vans were built
in greater numbers than the open wagons, following the preference for van
traffic evidenced in the vacuum braked services. Unlike the open wagons all
early batches of vans were piped to work with vacuum braked stock. Following the prototypes of 1966 the first air braked van design to
appear in 1969 was the COV-AB (TOPS coded VAB, the un-piped examples were VAA)
with half length sliding doors and with a single hooded vent at each end.
Variants on this were the non-vented VBA as offered by Graham Farish (it is
marked VAA but so were some BR vans) and VBB, a sub variant was the VBA-F which
may have been insulated. The bodies of all these vans were essentially similar,
the sides were identical. All had a 30 ton maximum load when running at 60 mph
but the maximum load at 70 mph was only 20 tons for the VAB and VBA, improved
suspension on the VBB allowed high speed running with about 24 tons. One common
use for these vans was the Rowntrees confectionery traffic from York.
VCA and VCB are variants on another standard design with centre sliding
doors and no end vent, some VCB's have lashing bars and these were sometimes
used for banana traffic. The maximum load at 60 mph is 30 tons, at 70 mph this
falls to about 25 tons. The VCA's proved less than successful and in the later
1980's many were transferred to other duties, quite a few ended up as barrier
vehicles whilst others were converted to FPA wagons for carrying thirty foot
long coal containers and some were sold to the Ministry of Defence. The VCA
chassis has been used for a number of Private Owner conversions, including (in
the later 1990's) a fleet of open wagons with high square ends and drop-down
mesh sides for Plasmor. These carry palletised lightweight concrete building
blocks from the factory to the depots.
The VDA/VDB appeared in 1976,
these have an external frame on the ends (as seen on some early prototype vans,
see sketch below), no end ventilator and hinged centre doors with separate
quarter doors at the outer ends. These could carry 31 tons at speeds of up to
60 mph but this was reduced to twenty one tons for speeds up to 70 mph. This
proved to be one of the more successful designs and they have remained in
demand throughout the 1990's. I believe they were the most common type of air
braked van built by BR.
In 1981 the prototype for a new van was
introduced on a new and longer chassis, this was the VGA, a 42 foot long,
sliding-wall van with a wheelbase of 29 feet 6 inches. Based on a German built
design originally produced for Ford (UK) these have proved to be a very
successful vehicles. The body had heavily ribbed ends and the roof forms only a
narrow strip along the centre line. Each side consisted of two sliding doors
made of light alloy and the upper part was bent inwards, forming part of the
roof. This arrangement allowed loads to be craned into the van and provides
easier access for fork lift trucks. To increase the carrying capacity the
section between the wheels was dropped to form a well and the actual capacity
of the vans was some 75 cubic metres with a 25 ton payload. Some VGA vans were
later fitted with modified bearings and coded VKA.
The last British
Railways van design was the VHA although I only know of one of these, a
prototype converted from a VDA. The VHA was an interesting 25 ton design with a
solid roof, low wooden drop sides and a plastic 'curtain' covering the upper
two thirds of the sides. Unlike the earlier curtain sided vans however the
curtain was supported on a light tubular metal frame and hinged upwards, which
saves a lot of time during loading and unloading. The prototype was later
converted to an OTA timber wagon (discussed below).
By the mid 1990's
of all these early van types only the VDA and VGA vans remained in regular
service although odd examples of all types were seen. The hinged and sliding
doors on the older vans have given problems and replacement curtain sides may
be fitted to many of those which are to remain in service.
Fig ___
British Railways standard air-braked rolling stock
In about 1980 several of the old ten foot wheelbase 'vanwide'
vans were converted to air brakes and re-coded VEA (for those with roller
bearings) and VFA (for those with roller bearings and an alarm). They were
intended for use carrying military supplies, the short wheelbase being better
suited to the tight curves in military establishments, but by the mid 1990's
these were all in departmental service and coded ZSA or ZRA.
In 1983
fifty of the old twelve foot wheelbase pipe wagons built by British Railways to
an LNER design were converted to air brakes and coded ODA also intended for
Ministry of Defence traffic.
The non-MGR air braked mineral hoppers
(HBA/HEA/HSA), originally intended for domestic coal traffic, appeared in 1975.
These wagons have a chassis which is about twenty five foot over headstocks
with a fifteen foot wheelbase. Taylor Plastic Models offer a body kit of this
wagon to suit the Peco fifteen foot wheelbase chassis. Some of these were later
fitted with a canvass roof with central roller, essentially similar to those on
the CDA china clay hoppers. These modified vehicles were coded CEA but I do not
know what traffic they were used for. I understand that the kit for modifying
the Minitrix HAA hopper can be used on the Taylor HBA body to produce a
CEA.
The steel industry has been one of the railways better customers
and British Railways has always operated large numbers of steel carrying
wagons. The unfitted bogie steel carriers built in the early British Railways
period were all scrapped or transferred to the engineers departments by the
early 1980's but some of the vacuum braked early British Railways designs
lasted into the early 1990's operating as block trains. By the mid 1990's only
new air braked designs and upgraded stock retro-fitted with new air braked
bogies were in service.
Quite a number of specialised steel carrying
wagons were built on the standard four wheeled air-braked chassis. The SAA was
the first to appear, three hundred of the type being built in 1971, the SAA had
drop-down posts along the sides and drop down ends. Taylor Plastic Models
offers a kit of such a vehicle to fit the TPM/Graham Farish chassis. Oddly
enough these were seldom used for steel and spent most of their working lives
as runner wagons. By the mid 1980's they were being re-coded as runners with
TOPS codes RRA RAB RBA and RRB.
The SCA (Coil C) 24.5 ton wagons
appeared in 1977, open wagons with four section steel drop sides and with a set
of hinged vertical side rails. These were built for wire and rod coil traffic
(mainly from South Wales) and were re-coded SAA in 1988 when the original SAAs
had all been transferred to runner duties.
Also in 1977 the first SPA
steel carrying wagons appeared, the modern version of the old plate wagons they
have a steel body with three section drop sides. Over a thousand of the type
were built and they were initially used for pig iron.
The SDA was a 2
axle bolster wagon, the SEA code was originally intended for a conversion of a
bogie wagon to a four wheeler but this was never completed and the code was
then used for a plate wagon with three section drop sides introduced in 1979.
The SFA is a variant of the SEA fitted with a nylon canvass 'tilt' so they can
carry unfinished steel sections.
By the mid 1980's there were twelve
types of four wheeled steel wagons listed in the TOPS 'S' series with another
eight two-axle coil types listed in the 'K' series (these were then re-coded in
the B and F series).
There has been a continuing program of up-grading
the steel carrying stock, funded by the steady profit from the traffic. As an
example the forty five foot long vacuum braked Bogie Bolster C were built to
carry thirty tons but were subsequently up-graded to 42 tons capacity and
fitted with air brakes (TOPS coded BCA). Similarly the forty two ton payload
fifty two foot long Bogie Bolster D of 1960's vintage was fitted with a
strengthened underframe and new air braked bogies in the late 1970's to handle
58 ton loads with a tare of 22.5 tons, these are TOPS coded BDA.
The
first new air braked bogie steel wagons to appear were three hundred or so 40
foot long Bogie Steel AB wagons, TOPS coded BAA, first built in 1972 and rated
at 76 tons payload. These were followed in 1973 by the BUA with a capacity of
42.5 tons and in 1975 by five hundred or so BBA. The BBA is a 52 foot wagon
rated at 74 tons payload, similar in appearance to the BAA but longer and with
deeper channel sections along the sides. In 1977 two hundred BMA (Bogie Coil M)
fifty foot long wide-body bolster type wagons rated at 58 tons were built. In
1979 the BOA bogie coil wagons were re-built for steel strip coil traffic,
these carry 53 tons apiece.
In the mid 1980's there were nineteen wagon
types listed in the B series (bogie steel wagons) and another twelve in the J
series (bogie coil wagons). The J series were then integrated in the B series
and there appear to have been some cases where old codes were re-used.
The French designed Debauch Vite wagon appeared in privately owned
British wagon fleets in the early 1980's, this has fixed ends similar to a
standard van but the body is a tarpaulin supported on a series of inverted U
shaped hoops. The hoops can be moved along the wagon (this is power assisted)
so the tarpaulin can be quickly drawn back allowing loads to be craned into the
wagon. These wagons proved popular for steel traffic as they offered protection
from the weather. In 1990 British Railways built four prototypes of three
essentially similar wagons, coded BGA (13m long 64 tons capacity), BHA (16m
long 61.5 tons capacity) and BJA (19m long 63 tons capacity). There are no
commercially available models of this general type but the design is
essentially simple to model. One option for this is discussed in the section on
Kit Bashing.
The very latest design is the EWS 100 ton bogie steel coil
wagon coded BYA. This is an unusual vehicles with a three section ribbed
telescopic roof. The design is reminiscent of the VTG owned German built
telescopic hood wagons (described in the section on PO wagon design) but the
hood is lower than on the German design and the tops of the hood sections are a
simple curved shape.
Fig ___ Modern steel carrying vehicles
The above form the backbone of the railway owned air
braked stock but there are many variants and modifications. Some of the
variants are available as models or kits, regarding which see the section on
available models. There were of course many conversions used for steel traffic,
amongst the air braked stock there were several four wheeled plate wagon
conversions such as the 31 ton SDA bolster, the 22.5 ton SEA rod-coil wagons,
the SHA (Coil T) 31.5 tons strip coil wagons and the SRA 24.5 ton rod-coil
wagons.
Timber traffic in Scotland has continued to be worthy of
railway investment and the OTA timber carrying wagons are similar to the old
Timber P vacuum braked vehicles but based on the longer air braked chassis. The
first lot were built using chassis from redundant OCA wagons in 1985, a later
batch was built using redundant VCA chassis. The OTA has solid ends but no
roof. Ranged along the sides are either twelve or thirteen sockets to hold
vertical posts and the load is strapped down using two straps attached to
fittings mounted between the side posts.
The MAA is a mineral tippler
built on redundant HAA merry-go-round hopper chassis and introduced in 1990.
These wagons have a simple box body with external framing which could be made
up quite easily using plastic card and microstrip. The chassis could be made up
using a Peco fifteen foot wheelbase chassis with a 4mm section cut from another
chassis inserted. The wheelbase would then be seventeen foot against the
prototypes nineteen, but this is cheaper than using expensive Minitrix HAA's as
the basis.
The MEA is another mineral tippler wagon, the prototypes
were built in the late 1980's and series production began in 1990. These wagons
were intended to replace the old MDV twenty one ton mineral wagons in South
Wales but have since found wider application throughout the system. The MEA
resembles the MAA but they use the shorter wheelbase chassis from redundant HBA
hopper wagon. The ribbing on the sides of the MEAs seen has been uneven with
the verticals near the centre closer together. This makes them a bit more
difficult to model than the MAA but they can run on a Peco fifteen foot
wheelbase chassis. The Peco chassis does need some of the brake gear removing
and a new long brake handle fitting but this is not difficult.
The
latest in this series of basic four wheel tipplers in the MKA, introduced in
about 1994 or 1995, these are built on ex Private Owner air braked chassis.
A half height version of the basic box body vehicle has been produced
in some numbers in the later 1990's, these are coded MFA and are used for
ballast.
In about 1999 a bogie box body wagon was introduced coded MBA,
these may be on former BBA steel carrying wagon chassis but I am not sure about
that. Four-wheeled container carrying wagons for ISO containers have been
produced from a number of British Railways wagon types. The first were based on
redundant plate wagons (of the type offered by Peco) and Lowmac vehicle
carriers.
In the 1970's experiments began using containers to carry
coal, I believe this was mainly in connection with traffic destined for
Ireland. A number of dual braked former 'ferry' plate wagons (again essentially
similar to those from Peco) had their vacuum brakes removed and fittings for
twenty foot ISO containers added. I believe these were used for twenty foot
coal containers, designed for use with standard ISO container handling gear but
lower than normal to fit within the loading gauge when sitting on a standard
height wagon. In the early 1980's some standard air braked SAA wagons were
converted to carry thirty foot coal containers. The container wagons are
discussed in more detail in the section on Unit Loads - Modern Containers, Road
Railer, Piggyback and Swap Bodies.
Fig ___ Air braked chassis
conversions
Carflats
are car carrying bogie flat wagons with a timber deck and a low rail running
along either side. They were developed for moving motor cars and saw extensive
service on the Motorail services (see Non passenger coaching stock - Motorail).
The carflats were built using redundant coach chassis are now mainly used for
commercial vehicles such as vans and are coded FVX under TOPS.
The
carflats were cheap, reliable and able to operate at high speeds, making them
well suited to Motorail duties, but they occupied a lot of siding space for a
given number of cars. In 1964 British Railways and Ford jointly developed an
articulated air-braked double-decked wagon consisting of four sections mounted
on four wheeled bogies with a total length of over two hundred and ten feet and
called the Cartic Four. These required much less siding space for a given load
(typically between about a third and a half less space), some were used for the
Motorail services when demand was high. The British Railways owned Cartic
Four's (TOPS coded FQA) were withdrawn and held in reserve in the 1980's, they
are painted rail blue with no markings, there remained over a hundred Private
Owner sets operating however, mostly owned by Procor and MAT. These are TOPS
coded PQA. An etched brass kit of the cartic four is available to members of
the N Gauge society but bear in mind that just two Cartic Four units require
about three foot of siding in N.
The Autic Six (coded PJA under TOPS)
is articulated two-unit six-wheeled drop-centre and double decked car
transporter. They are about ninety two foot long, actually based on a French
design and the British version was built for Cartransport (a division of
National Freight Carriers) by Standard Railway Wagon Co in 1981. The first user
for these wagons was British Leyland but they have also been used for other
firms cars. The Lima six wheeler articulated car carrier is the closest
available design to represent these vehicles, a single Lima double-unit could
pass for an Autic Six although the side framing is slightly different.
In the late 1980's many Cartics and Autics were fitted with white or
black plastic panels on the sides to protect the cars from stones thrown by
children, some also had a curved corrugated black plastic roof added.
The Cartic Four carried about 24 cars, it was not economic for smaller
numbers as the charges were based on the hire of the vehicle not its load.
Procor introduced their Procar 80 to fill this gap, offering economic transport
of loads down to 8-10 cars. The Procar 80 is a double decked bogie vehicle
eighty three foot long, the longest non-articulated vehicle on British rails.
Renault was first user, hiring the wagons to transport cars imported at Goole.
The nearest ready to run model in N was the Ibertren bogie car carrier although
this is a little short and difficult to find these days.
The restricted
British loading gauge remains a problem for larger road vehicles such as
commercial vans and the like. These cannot fit inside the articulated wagons
and are too high to ride on the carflats. British Railways have converted a
number of Freightliner bogie flat wagons for moving these larger vehicles. This
vehicle carrying conversion is fitted with a wooden floor and has buffers at
both ends (unlike the standard Freightliner wagons). The buffer beams are above
the height of the deck so short ramps are built into the ends to allow vehicles
to be driven off over the buffers on to standard height loading bays. I believe
this is a British Railways owned conversion but I am unable to confirm details
of the livery.
The 'Comtic' is a single decked version of the Autic Six
(it has been described as an articulated Lomac) these are used for larger
vehicles and TOPS coded PKA. The comtics were first purchased by MAT-Transauto
and I believe they were introduced in 1984. Leyland/Daf used these wagons to
move articulated lorry tractor units from Leyland to the docks in the later
1980's. These could be modelled fairly convincingly by removing the upper deck
and its supporting pillars from a Lima articulated car carrier. The Autic and
Comtic wagons appeared in a number of liveries, often specified by the company
whose vehicles they carried, for example Renault had them painted yellow with
the Renault name in black on a white patch somewhere about the centre.
Inter-factory traffic has declined with changes in the motor industry
but some still remains on the railways. The Peco 'palvan' represents a design
built at Ashford in the 1960's for Ford, the model is actually rather short as
the prototype was closer in size to the Graham Farish air braked van. These
vans travelled as a block working between Dagenham in Essex and Halewood near
Liverpool. Later Ford used forty seven foot long leased wagons, developed by
Cargowaggon, these are described in the section on PO Air Braked Stock.
Fords international spares and parts movement was all containerised by
the early 1980's and so travelled on Freightliner services.
In the
1970's and 1980's British Leyland used rail for moving body pressings from the
Pressed Steel plant at Swindon to factories at Cowley (near Oxford) and
Longbridge but I have not been able to confirm the vehicle types used for this
traffic.
To cater for British Leyland traffic, specifically engines, BR
modified some of its very large four wheeled ferry vans in the late 1960's or
early 1970s (British Leyland was only formed in 1968). These were coded VQX I
believe. The sides were removed and replaced with dark blue curtain sides
(Humbrol Oxford Blue is a fair match I believe), the curtain sides had the logo
and company name on them in white. The ends and roof were all painted in a very
slightly lighter blue than the curtains. These vehicles retained the RIV
international ferry markings and fittings (the markings were moved to the ends
as shown below) and the securing lugs remained in place but I do not know if
they were used for export traffic or if they operated between BL factories in
the UK. By the early 1980's they were stored out of use.
Fig___
British Leyland (ex BR Ferry) Van
The advantage here
is that the curtain side is much easier to model than the sides and
drop-flap ventilators on the sides of the original ferry vans. A model, in N,
should be 86.5mm over headstocks with a wheelbase of 54mm. The curtain sides
should be 14mm high and wrap over the ends by about 0.5mm. The two rows of
small white rings on the drawing are the lacing rings for the sides, the upper
row were along the bottom edge of a separate short curtain near the top of the
sides. As noted by Bernard Taylor in his article of BR Ferry Wagons in
Practical Model Railways magazine (see bibliography) the long wheelbase of this
vehicle makes for problems on the tight curves of a model railway. He built his
model of the ferry van on a continental steel wagon chassis which had pivoted
axles for this very reason.
Future Developments
Predicting the future is
notoriously risky, as railway planners have found repeatedly since the early
nineteenth century. There are some trends which seem likely to continue however
such as a steady increase in mechanical handling and the containerisation not
only of finished goods but also raw materials. The steady increase in container
size has resulted in further developments in rolling stock such as the
drop-centred 'pocket' wagons used by Freightliners Ltd.
The 'Piggy-back'
wagon, carrying articulated road trailers is an idea supported by the European
Union, again the constraints of the British loading gauge has produced some
interesting new ideas for piggy-back rolling stock. One notable example is the
Eurospine wagon designed by Thrall which can carry both road trailers and
containers. Again this is not such a new idea, the Americans have been carrying
road trailers on 'piggy-back' services since the 1960's and in the early 1980's
a German firm called Talbot introduced a low-loading bogie wagon which could
carry both the tractor unit and its trailer. These latter were formed into long
rakes and used for a 'rolling-highway' service between West Germany, Holland,
Italy and Switzerland. The lorry drivers were carried in coaches at the rear of
the train. The French, who benefit from a more generous loading gauge, have
been operating special wagons carrying road trailers for several years. In the
early 1980's Procor worked on a British version but the constraints of the
British loading gauge proved too much of an obstacle, especially as road
vehicle sizes continued to increase.
First in the field was Eurospine,
a fixed rake of four articulated units each capable of carrying a low height
road trailer or a forty foot long standard ISO container. Eurospine was
developed by the American specialist company Thrall Car (who now have a
European division) and the pre-production prototype was shown to the public in
late 1996. This is not an entirely new type of vehicle, the design is derived
from an American wagon called the Fuel Foiler which entered service in the
1970's, but the British version has to contend with much tighter clearances
along the track. Services began with two sets in 1998 carrying Post Office
'Parcels Force' trailers but EWS have ordered over a hundred of these sets.
Each Eurospine unit consists of a hefty central spar with cross-beams toward
the ends to support the ends of a container and a pair of platforms mounted on
the sides to carry the road wheels of an articulated lorry trailer. The
trailers have to be lifted on by a crane, current practice favours a very large
'fork lift' type vehicle equipped with a special lifting frame in place of the
forks. John Grey offers a model of the Eurospine wagon in his etched brass
range of kits. The complete four-wagon articulated set is just over fifty nine
and a half meters or one hundred and ninety six feet long, that corresponds to
some 40cm or 15 inches in British N.
Meanwhile Freightliners were also
taking an interest in this method of transport, they worked with Frauhauf (the
road trailer builders) and Exel TankFreight (a logistics firm) to design and
produce some semi-trailers for chemicals. These are moved on redundant
low-loading wagons initially built and leased by Charter Rail for pet food
traffic under Speedlink. These wagons and road-rail tank semi-trailers were
introduced into service between the Freightliner depots in Manchester (Trafford
Park) and London. The Trafford Park terminal has been equipped with two new 23m
high transporter cranes to handle this traffic. The cranes were in part paid
for by a Freight Facilities Grant, they use standard lifting frames for
containers and a special frame with four long drop arms to lift the trailers.
Pocket wagons have a dropped section between the wheels or bogies,
similar to the old Flatrol or Welltrol wagons but with sides to the well
forming a 'pocket'. These wagons can carry taller than normal containers,
notably the nine foot six inch high types which are becoming increasingly
common on the 'deep-sea' container shipping routes.
Latest to enter the
field are Babcock (famous for their steam boiler plant) who have developed a
vehicle called the Mega 3 Pocket wagon. The Babcock wagons can carry a road
semi-trailer, two twenty foot long containers or a single road/rail swap-body.
The swap-body is a road-rail container shaped like a standard lorry
semi-trailer body which can be transported on railway wagons or on a purpose
built skeletal road semi-trailer. They are not built to ISO container
specifications (they are not the right size and they have different securing
methods), they cannot be stacked or transported on container carrying ships.
They are designed specifically to carry standard size pallets and better meet
the needs of a straight road-rail transportation service. They are a couple of
inches (about 5cm) wider than the ISO standard container, and hence run into
clearance problems on the British rail network but Freightliners Ltd. has
experimented with them.
Sketches of the Eurospine and Pocket Wagons
have been included in the section on Unit Loads - Modern Containers, Road
Railer, Piggyback and Swap Bodies.
The European Economic Community is
very interested in rail haulage for road lorries and they plan a Europe-wide
trunk rail network offering high speed transits. The British are having
difficulty deciding who might pay for the increased clearances to allow such
services in the UK. Initial estimates were that it would take £100
million to upgrade the line from Scotland to the Channel Tunnel to carry nine
foot six inch high containers and full size lorry trailers. This cost then
bloomed under Railtrack until the entire project was effectively put on
indefinite hold. At the time of writing (2003) I am not aware of any plans to
start work on this.
Europe has now evolved a plan for a Europe wide
network and the intention is that, in the future, train operating companies
will be able to operate through-services Europe-wide to increase competition
and hopefully efficiency. The plan includes considerable provision for the nine
foot six inch high containers, road trailer transporters and swap body vehicles
but as most countries on the continent meet the loading gauge requirements of
the Berne Convention work is proceeding quite quickly on this project. The
British have recently indicated that they feel it would be uneconomic for them
to provide the investment in infrastructure to achieve similar clearances
throughout the British network. Platforms would need to be cut back, bridges
and tunnels altered and the overhead catenary wires would need to be lifted to
allow European stock and engines to roam about the British system. I believe
they are prepared, in theory at least, to upgrade some lines and provide maps
for Continental train operators so that rolling stock suitable for use on
unmodified British lines can be routed through the system.
Still on the
drawing board are a number of vehicles which may yet see light of day. One
interesting idea is the self-propelled goods wagon, this is really an extension
of the old idea of the diesels parcels carriers of the 1950's and the new
parcels multiple units used for Royal Mail traffic. The new machines would be
able to operate as multiple units with perhaps three or four conventional
un-powered wagons in tow. The designs under consideration include curtain sided
pallet carriers and even hooded steel carrying wagons.
Research into
the use of aircraft style containers on the railways is also in progress,
building on the experience with the Mini-Link container and the more recent
Royal Mail containerised parcels services with their associated purpose built
multiple units. The most recent manifestation of this concept is the Minimodal
system, which uses simple square sheet metal containers, the initial standard
version has a roller shutter door in one side. These can be placed on rail
wagons or road trailers, if the door is to the side they can be loaded whilst
on the vehicle, if not they are secure from break-in when parked in a lay-by.
Quoting from Minimodal.com
The Minimodal Unit Load
The Minimodal unit load has a 2.55 metre square base, the maximum road width of a lorry, which can be rotated for side loading from both sides and end loading - individually and in series.
Minimodal units have four way fork pockets, provision for top lift, may be connected together to form a 7.82 metre swap body, are stackable and secure. The Minimodal format can be adapted for dry goods, chilled produce, liquids & gases, waste, hoppers and as a flat carrier.
Any suitably rated flatbed road vehicle will carry Minimodal. Heavy goods vehicles can carry up to 6 Minimodal units, smaller goods vehicles can carry fewer. Standard container-flat rail wagons can convey Minimodal by rail.
The Minimodal container services have now started, sponsored by EWS and
they could provide a useful service to parcels carriers, supermarkets and other
organisations with a high volume traffic that requires rapid
handling.
It is generally accepted that the railways now offer better
time reliability than road haulage and new investment has seen the evolution of
advanced technology solutions. Whilst it is highly unlikely that the railways
will ever regain the mass of small scale traffic they once handled they are in
a position to offer cost effective solutions to logistics managers.